Medical Necessity Denied? How to Prove Your Doctor Was Right

Introduction

One of the most frustrating rejection reasons is "Lack of Medical Necessity." Essentially, the insurance company is questioning your doctor's judgment, claiming the treatment or procedure wasn't essential for your health.

However, this is often a technical disagreement rather than a final medical verdict. Here is how you can prove the treatment was necessary and get your claim approved.

---

Step 1: Define "Medical Necessity"

In the eyes of an insurer, a service is medically necessary if it is:

• Consonant with the diagnosis and treatment of your condition.
• Not primarily for the convenience of the patient or physician.
• The most appropriate level of service that can be safely provided.

Understanding this definition helps you tailor your appeal to meet their specific criteria.

---

Step 2: Obtain a "Letter of Medical Necessity" (LMN)

The most powerful tool in your arsenal is a formal letter from your treating physician. A standard prescription is not enough.

An effective LMN should include:

• Clinical History: A brief summary of your diagnosis and previous failed treatments (if any).
• Evidence-Based Support: References to peer-reviewed studies or clinical guidelines that support the treatment.
• The "Risk of Non-Treatment": A clear explanation of what would happen to your health if the claim remains denied.

---

Step 3: Peer-to-Peer Review

If the written appeal is struggling, request a Peer-to-Peer Review. This is a phone call between your doctor and the insurance company’s medical director.

During this call, your doctor can advocate for you directly, physician-to-physician, often clearing up misunderstandings that a paper trail might miss.

---

Step 4: Organize Your Clinical Evidence

Don't just send the letter; send the supporting data. Ensure your appeal package includes:

• Relevant lab results or imaging reports (MRIs, CT scans).
• Progress notes from your last three consultations.
• A copy of the specific Clinical Policy Bulletin (CPB) the insurer uses for your condition.

---

Step 5: The External Review

If the internal appeal fails, you have the right to an Independent External Review. In this stage, a third-party medical expert—with no ties to your insurance company—reviews your case. Their decision is usually binding for the insurer.

---

Conclusion

Proving medical necessity is about connecting the dots between your doctor's expertise and the insurance company's policy language. By providing detailed clinical evidence and staying persistent, you can overturn a denial and prioritize your health.